Waking from Machine Dreams (Yes, It’s Artificial, No it’s Not Intelligence)

The concept of the Industrial Revolution was that machines could make life easier for humans, and that’s been generally true, but at a cost.

The idea of the Information Age is that having more information is always good. And it is, up to a point. We need to remember that information isn’t knowledge, and knowledge isn’t wisdom.

The comments at the most recent Culver City Council meeting on the Flock surveillance cameras were just one snapshot of how much people feel that the machines are over-reaching, and that this needs to be stopped.

At a council meeting in October, both Council member Dan O’Brien and Vice Mayor Bubba Fish talked about A.I. from the dais, in regard to a request for an event. Both of them made some sharp observations. People have, in fact, lost their livelihoods. The continued growth of information technology has it’s upside, but is so problematic for the humans having to deal with it, we may have reached a tipping point.

If you know the book “Dune” by Frank Herbert, you may have already come across this idea; somewhere in the deep history of their civilization, there was an event known as the ‘Butlerian Jihad’ described as a ‘crusade by the last free humans to destroy the thinking machines.’ Pretty interesting for a book published in 1965, when phones were still attached to cords and having a color television set was considered peak modernity.

Like any tool, it is up to us to choose how to use it. One of my teachers once noted that you can use a hammer to build a house, or you can use it to break someone’s skull. It’s not up to the hammer, it’s up to you.

As someone with a very low threshold of ‘uncanny valley’ – I do in fact get a sense of physical ick when I have to interact with something that isn’t human, pretending to be human. Nothing chills my blood faster than the words “Hi, I’m your new AI assistant and I can understand what you say…tell me why you are calling.” Because, truly, 99 times out of a hundred, they CAN’T understand what I say, they cut me off mid-sentence, they keep asking me to repeat the same (accurate) information over and over until I’m just repeating the phrase “speak to a representative…” until I can get a human being on the line.

This is supposed to be more efficient and helpful. It’s neither. It’s time consuming and annoying. And probably expensive.

The comments against the cameras – some of which were misinterpreted as comments against the police – had a lot to do with over-reach. You can never turn the camera off. There is no real way to keep this data secure. And how to even begin with Flock and their multiple, nationwide reports of lying to potential customers about what this system can and can’t do? That last one is human error…but … humans are the ones employing the machines.

That software that keeps offering to write my emails? No thanks, I like to make own sentences. It’s fun.

The folks who are big fans of the promise of A.I. are all sort of whistling in the dark – they truly don’t know what they don’t know ( and cannot admit that they don’t know.)

The Microsoft crash last week that had me locked out for an afternoon reminded me of Mickey Mouse as the Sorcerer’s Apprentice, waving his fingers and whistling as a broom brought buckets of water to fill the wizard’s bath. And then his room. And then the whole castle. Because he’s using a tool without knowing how to use it.

Of course, the fact that all this is ‘private enterprise’ is the failure. No oversight, no regulation, just more software “agents” being unleashed without any understanding of what they do.

I have seen little glimmers – videos online with a “NO AI” logos, announcements from radio stations the they are “Created entirely by humans.” Perhaps the value of human-made things will rise, as the advent of “AI slop, ” becomes more irritating than helpful.

I have to vote with Writer Michael Pollan who argues that it’s failure is inevitable, as it’s all built on a false metaphor; the mind is not a machine. It’s something much more nuanced and mysterious.

Will there even be a Butler to name the crusade after? Perhaps it will be more of a butler’s pantry, a space between where useful – truly useful – things can be created.

Judith Martin-Straw

 

The Actors' Gang