City Council Ends Flock Surveillance Camera Contract, “Immediately”

“What does public safety require and what does it cost…Do the risks outweigh the benefits?”

When it was Vice Mayor Bubba Fish’s turn to speak at the Nov. 16, 2026 City Council meeting on the agenda item in regard to the city’s contract with Flock for ALPR cameras, he cut right to the heart of the question.

The decision to “Cease all use of Flock [cameras] and terminate [the contract] immediately” passed on a vote of three to two.

The agenda item was a major concern for the community, with just under 50 people signed up to speak from the podium, and many offering examples of why the city should stop using the technology. The majority of speakers urged the council to end the Flock contract.

Interim Chief of Police Troy Dunlap and Assistant Chief Andrew Bellante gave a presentation on how the Culver City Police Department had utilized the camera information, with specific crimes being illustrated. They also included a timeline of changes to the user agreement after July of 2025 – a month that saw Immigration Customs and Enforcement inflicting terror on Culver City residents.

Two other presentation – one from the American Civil Liberties Union and one from the Electronic Frontier Foundation – highlighted issues with both Flock as a company and ALRP technology in general. Rin Alajaji, the associate director for EFF, noted that the non-profit has been litigating against ALPR since 2012. Their baseline is that “ALRP is warrantless surveillance,” as specifically prohibited by the U.S. Constitution.

The ACLU of SoCal, represented by staff attorney Alissa Morones, offered that the tech had a “significant impact on our civil right and civil liberties.” Noting that “ALPRs undermine the right to privacy, and [they] allow the government to track everyone’s data and movements… When Flock notes that they track cars, and not people, it’s important to remember that people drive cars.”

In terminating the contract with Flock, Culver City became one of more than 30 cities in the state of California to do so. Cities including Bishop, Sacramento, Santa Cruz, and just recently, Los Angeles have all ended their use of Flock cameras.

How effective the technology is has become a secondary issue to the many problems with the Flock company. This has been a central concern; while the company maintains that the data is secure, there’s a great deal of evidence that it is not.

Fish offered that ten years ago, a different council had opted not to work with an ALPR company called Vigilant, and five later in 2023, another council had agreed to the contract with Flock on a three to two vote.

“What’s become clear is that this tech is fundamentally different. It’s always on, it’s never off. [Rather than take a picture of an infraction, like a red-light camera,] it tracks everyone. It give law enforcement unfettered access …The legality of this technology is still an open question.”

Fish also noted that the margin of error has been shown to be extreme. “LAPD let their contract with Flock expire after [data showed that] within two months almost one out of three ‘stolen car alerts’ were wrong. That meant 161 people mistakenly pulled over as suspected car thieves.”

The errors are all part of the tech. “This is not about our officers,” the Vice Mayor said, “I know CCPD takes their responsibilities seriously. It’s about technology that [we] don’t control.”

“Just tonight, the City of San Diego voted unanimously – that’s seven to zero – to end their ALPR contracts…for the same reasons.”

The vote was three to two, with both Council member Dan O’Brien and Council member Albert Vera, Jr. voting ‘no.’ After the vote results were announced the audience in the Mike Balkman Council Chambers burst into applause.

Judith Martin-Straw

 

 

The Actors' Gang